The page seems to only be about weapons required to get the trophy? The title suggests it would be about all valuable/unique/named weapons, so perhaps there should be another category of weapons that don't contribute to the trophy (but are named, one-off drops)?
Date: 04 Mar 2010 01:30
Number of posts: 4
RSS: New posts
That is a good point. I often wondered about the name. I'll change it so that it matches what it is intended for. As for another page that has the valuable/unique/named weapons, please create it. Once you do, I'll put it on the navigation bar for you.
I notice all the weapons on the page are "confirmed" for the trophy now. To get clarification I sent the user this message, hopefully he will followup here:
I notice you edited the Demon's Souls page and confirmed all 4 of the remaining weapons as needed for the soldier's trophy. Can I ask you the source of your information? It seems a real challenge to confirm all of these, since you have to start clean with a new user/character and get a different one last to test each one. Is this from your own testing, or others you know, or from other forum sources? If you are confident on the data, then we should edit the page and can remove the redundant confirmation information, since this means all the weapons are actually needed.
Do all weapons need to be possessed by the same character, or can they be spread between characters on the same account? I've seen random posts by people who claim to have gotten the trophy without collecting all the weapons on a single character, but I've never heard anything authoritative about which way it works.